|
Have you ever wondered what Mozart's playing was like? Or how a
Strauss waltz sounded to the composer's contemporary audience? It's
hard for us to remember that recording equipment is a relatively
recent invention, that most performances, great and small, have been
lost to history. I think of Lincoln as sounding like Hal Holbrook, or
that Disney animatronic from the New York World's Fair. Silly, isn't
it?
Which brings me to this disc of Gershwin performances. Any recording
of Gershwin's time would of necessity be a pale shadow of the real
thing. Even the best digital processing can't recreate the ambience
of a real performance; it can only offer a simulation based on our own
guesses and prejudices.
Here, on the other hand, is something from Gershwin's own hands.
These tracks are recreated from piano rolls made in the early part of
the last century. The piano sound is modern, and as perfect as our
recording technology allows. The pacing is original, at least to the
degree a player piano system could capture it. The timing
is right; what's missing is the precise control, the soft and hard
hard hitting of the keys. There's a particular sound to a player
piano, a loss of variation and subtlety that must have been present in
the original.
Still, for those of us who aren't a hundred years old, this is as
close as we'll get to an original performance. It's as if Gershwin's
ghost has returned for a little visit.
|