Maybe it's our cynical age. Maybe I'm just getting cranky, or at
least crankier. But I find myself less and less sure of things as I
get older. More suspicious of those who
are sure, who claim
some special pipeline to God. And a lot less surprised when something
I've known and taken for granted forever turns out not to be true.
The source of this minor revelation was this week's episode of the
radio series
This American Life on
NPR. Early in the broadcast, they discussed Ben Franklin's famous
experiment with lightning, which my older brother once described
thusly:
"Benjamin Franklin, inventor was he.
Out in a storm with a kite and a key.
Proved how electric the lightning can be."
Which I'm sure wasn't original with him, but that's beside the point.
Anyway, the gist of the story was that the whole business with the key
probably didn't happen. There's a mention in Franklin's early
writings where he suggests that such an experiment could be done, with
no indication that he had done, or intended to do, the deed himself.
It was only many years later, in perhaps a benign attempt to pad his
resume for future generations, that he claimed to have been out in
that storm. What's funny of course is that few people had resumes
that needed padding less than old Ben.
Anyway, I'm surprised that I'm not really surprised. I've known that
George Washington and the cherry tree was a crock since I was in
junior high. And Columbus didn't have to convince anyone that
the world was round, a fact we used in a school play in the third
grade. (Actually, he did come up with one revelation regarding the
size of the earth. Turns out in that case that he was wrong and
conventional wisdom was right.) But Franklin and the kite? At the
age of fifty I still bought that one.
And yet I'm neither shocked nor upset to lose another historic
tableau. In part that's because it doesn't really matter. And in
part, I guess, because I've learned to take most of what we're taught
with a "Lot's wife"-sized grain of salt. Even in an age of video
cameras we can be bamboozled by those concerned with a higher
purpose. (The Jessica Lynch story comes to mind.) How much easier
was it in an age where direct evidence was so much harder to come by?